Document Type : Original article
Authors
1 PhD student at the Research Institute for Hawzah and University
2 Faculty Member at Kharazmi University
Abstract
the concept of emotion has long been a central yet challenging subject in psychology. Recent theories in affective neuroscience differ significantly in defining and explaining emotion. This study aims to review the major theories in the neuropsychology of emotion from the past decade and critique them based on Islamic anthropology. Using a meta-synthesis approach, five leading theories are identified and compared. The analysis raises four major critiques: (1) failure to explain the relationship between emotional intensity and behavioral responses, (2) inability to account for the interaction between cognition and emotion, (3) lack of clarity on how emotions influence behavior, and (4) conflating the concept of emotion with its generating processes. The study also highlights empirical limitations of viewing the brain as the central locus of emotion, including: ambiguity in identifying relevant brain regions, difficulty in functional analysis, and lack of evidence for causal roles. From the perspective of Islamic anthropology, additional critiques include the reduction of the human being to a material entity, limiting emotion to biological and adaptive functions, neglecting free will, and ignoring innate emotional foundations. Ultimately, the study proposes a soul-centered (nafs-oriented) model as a more comprehensive framework for understanding emotion.
Keywords
Main Subjects