In collaboration with Payame Noor University and Iran Neuropsychology Association

Document Type : Review article

Author

Assistant Professor, Department of Psychology, Payame Noor University, Tehran, Iran.

10.30473/clpsy.2026.80060.1849

Abstract

Executive functions are widely proposed as a cognitive foundation of writing, yet the validity of the measures used to study this relation has received little attention. This critical review examined how executive functions are measured in writing research and what the validity of these measures implies for learning and instruction. Methods and Materials: A narrative critical review of 50 sources (empirical studies, systematic reviews and meta-analyses, and methodological papers) on text composition in children and adolescents was conducted. Sources were found through a targeted search in October 2026, with control searches in PubMed and ERIC; bibliographic details were checked against publisher or Crossref records, and findings were compared narratively without statistical pooling. Results: The relation between executive functions and writing was positive but small (standardized coefficients about 0.15 to 0.19). Six findings emerged: heterogeneous measures; test-retest reliability from 0 to 0.82; weak convergence between performance-based tests and ratings (about 24% of correlations significant); vague use of the term ecological validity (about one third of 90 articles); effects that were mostly indirect, through transcription and text-specific skills; and a key executive component that changed with outcome and timing. Iranian studies mainly compared clinical groups or tested interventions. Conclusion: A score on one executive function test should not be read as an explanation of a student’s writing difficulty. Multi-method assessment, reliability reporting, separation of transcription, and validated Persian measures are needed. The findings are provisional because the search was targeted and many sources were read at abstract level.

Keywords

Main Subjects